SIDEBAR
»
S
I
D
E
B
A
R
«
Same Button, Different Meaning
Aug 27th, 2009 by Eugene Ostroukhov

Consider following two images: wizard

wizard_progressHere you can see what I consider as a major UI antipattern – Cancel button has two distinct roles. In the first case it works as a close button on the window title bar – if the user clicks it, the wizard dialog will close and the user input will be lost. In the bottom case the Cancel button is a “Cancel task” button – the task will be stopped but the dialog will be retained. This is pretty confusing for the users as they are not sure if they loose input in later case. I suggest we introduce a new button that will explicitly stop the task but has nothing to do with wizard dialog:

stopbuttonThis way Cancel button always mimics Close Window button – i.e. it is grayed out when the wizard dialog cannot be closed. I filed this enhancement suggestion (along with a patch) as bug 287887 in Eclipse.org bugtracker.

»  Substance:WordPress   »  Style:Ahren Ahimsa